*** Soapbox warning! ***

I have been trying, literally for years, to have someone show me a BSA document "outlawing" fixed blade knives. I consider this somewhat akin to an "urban legend," except Scouts are supposed to be outing... and not urbaning.... <img src="/images/graemlins/cool.gif" alt="" />

The Bible of Scouting, a.k.a. The Guide to Safe Scouting, does not prohibit fixed blade knives. Think about food preparation and the types of knives frequently used therein.

Having said that, knives are tools, and it is important to learn to use the appropriate tool for the task. Most camp chores are well suited to small knives, and folders are inheriently safer when folded and not in use than a fixed blade.

Fixed blades may not be PC, but they're not banned (unless for specific events, e.g., a camporee) and they're sometimes useful.

Please don't take this as a recommendation to go out and get a fixed blade knife. The choice of knife depends on an almost infinite number of factors, including, in many cases, attitudes of others. I just feel it necessary to correct some myths/misunderstandings.

/Neal

Eagle Scout, Scouter and the usual woods tools instructor for most of our Council training.