I had a discussion about this paper with someone who has access to the original. They tested 6 knots, and ranked them. They didn't find the "6 best knots". The order of the knots are:

1. Zeppelin
2. Alpine butterfly
3. Reef
4. Granny
5. Thief
6. Grief (aka "Whatnot" in Ashley)
_________________________
- Benton