Originally Posted By: Tjin
Some say to replace the tires because the rubber compound starts to harden en you lose some of the grip provided by that soft rubber.

I suppose the question is: how deep does that hardening go? I have no hard evidence on that, though my tire guys say it is only skin deep -- as soon as you run on clear asphalt or concrete, the hard skin is worn off.

Originally Posted By: Tjin
Some people want to squeeze the remaining life out of the winter tires by driving from 4mm to 1.6mm (legal limit) in summer.

I have done that on occasion. As you say, there is a cost in fuel efficiency. Handling is affected also, though not so much that a capable driver cannot compensate. It helps to increase the tire pressure to the maximum listed on the tire itself. Still, it is a compromise, and from a survival point of view, tires are a terrible place to compromise.