Originally Posted By: Montanero
Bottom line, we don't know what we don't know, and science is not perfect. A little caution should be tolerated and not be a political weapon. Implementation of policies by poorly trained people is always rough and difficult, but we should err on the side of caution.

Too much of the current policies recommended relies on individual cooperation and honesty. My experience with human beings is that many are not honest and will take a narcissistic attitude to take care of their own desires.

We can take caution and protect civil rights at the same time, they are not mutually exclusive.

According to an article in the NY Times, people who even work in the same hospital where an ebola patient is being treated are now being stigmatized, even if they are not in any way connected with treating the patient.
Quote:
For six years, Mayra Martinez had been going to the same beautician in Queens, and considered her a friend. On Saturday, while getting her hair done, Ms. Martinez, 45, mentioned she had just gotten a new job. “Where?” the beautician asked. “Bellevue,” Ms. Martinez said. “She just froze and asked, ‘Are you anywhere near him?” Ms. Martinez recalled. Then the beautician asked her to please find someone else to do her hair. By “him,” the beautician meant Dr. Craig Spencer, who is New York’s first Ebola patient. As Bellevue Hospital Center goes into its seventh day of treating Dr. Spencer, who had worked with Doctors Without Borders in Guinea, some of its employees are feeling stigmatized — a harsh consequence of being the first hospital in the city to deal with an outbreak that has killed about 5,000 people in West Africa, and which is known to kill about half the people who become infected.

Bellevue’s medical director, Dr. Nate Link, said more than a dozen employees — not limited to those taking care of Dr. Spencer — had reported being discriminated against, including not being welcome at a business or social event. One employee lost a teaching position, he said.

Closer to home for me, a school district has had dispel ebola fears when a teacher returned from a vacation to South Africa, 3,000 miles from the area of the epidemic.

Unfortunately, the "better safe than sorry" approach is subject to the Law of Unintended Consequences. Quarantining people without good, solid, medically supported reasons only serves to increase the general paranoia about ebola. The unintended consequence is that if people think they are going to be stigmatized just for working in the same huge hospital as an ebola patient, or for traveing anywhere on the continent of Africa (no matter how far from the epidemic), then this just increases the incentive to be less than truthfull about where you have been, what you have done, and who you have been near. Thus your "....experience with human beings is that many are not honest and will take a narcissistic attitude to take care of their own desires" becomes a self fullfilling prophecy.


Edited by AKSAR (10/29/14 08:53 PM)
_________________________
"Toto, I've a feeling we're not in Kansas any more."
-Dorothy, in The Wizard of Oz