I have had Gore-Tex lined boots from a variety of companies: Danner, Scarpa, Lowa, Vasque, North Face, etc. I always wore out the soles before the uppers or the Gore-tex lining showed much wear at all. They are great for cold and wet conditions. I generally use them year around, my feet sweat in sandals so the Gore-Tex is no worse, just a bit warmer. I look for the durability of the boot and how well they wear on my feet. everyone is different, so you have to do a bit of discovery learning to see what works for you. My favorites were Vasque and Scarpa.