My barber doesn't make life and death decisions for me or my family.
I would expect a health care professional that may have to make life and death decisions for my family to be able to think on their feet, exhibit some problem solving and planning skills.
Like I said, I don't consider the sad events in Death Valley to be de facto evidence that she's incompetent but (in my opinion
) they can't be completely ignored either.
We obviously don't agree whether or not her inability to plan or problem solve in this situation has any relation to her vocational abilities. I can't completely separate one group of decisions from the other. If you can then great. Everyone is entitled to their own opinion right?