I've owned both my AR-7 was from charter arms though. They both have their pros and cons, but reliability the papoose is the best, but the AR-7 is easier to work on. Once you get them sighted they are about the same. Ease of carry goes to the AR-7 but the wide stock is uncomfortable but it floats. The papoose is comfortable but it dosen't break down as good as the AR-7 and it sinks like a rock. Overall I like the looks of the papoose better too.