Equipped To Survive Equipped To Survive® Presents
The Survival Forum
Where do you want to go on ETS?

Page 1 of 2 1 2 >
Topic Options
#93839 - 05/06/07 09:55 PM A question about water
norad45 Offline
Veteran

Registered: 07/01/04
Posts: 1506
Is there a point beyond which water cannot be consumed even if you boil it? Assuming no chemical contamination, can you boil water to make it potable no matter how long it has been stored? The reason I ask is that I can envision a scenario where I have a whole lot of propane, a stove, a metal pot, and 40 gallons of water that has been stored at +90 F. for 3 months. Suppose that water is literally dripping with algae and assorted creepy-crawleys. Can it safely be drunk after straining and boiling, or will toxins (botulism, salmonella, etc.) which cannot be removed by boiling build up in the supply, thereby making it deadly?

Top
#93840 - 05/06/07 10:05 PM Re: A question about water [Re: norad45]
big_al Offline
Addict

Registered: 01/04/06
Posts: 586
Loc: 20mi east of San Diego


To the best of my knowlage, After you have strained and filtered the water, then bringing it to a rolling boil the water is good to drink no matter how long it has been stored or wher it came from.

_________________________
Some people try to turn back their odometers.
Not me, I want people to know "why" I look this way
I've traveled a long way and some of the roads weren't paved

Top
#93842 - 05/06/07 11:03 PM Re: A question about water [Re: big_al]
benjammin Offline
Rapscallion
Carpal Tunnel

Registered: 02/06/04
Posts: 4020
Loc: Anchorage AK
Well, you can filter the water for pathogens and other biologic organisms, and you can boil whatever might make it through long enough that you can destroy those organisms as well. However, some organisms create toxins which can pass through filters and will not be destroyed by boiling.

There are some organisms that live in the heated pools in Yellowstone that I think would be pretty bad if you tried to ingest them. I think they can tolerate up to 180 degrees F or so, but boiling may be just a bit too much for them.

Pasteurizing may be the best disinfectant process going so far as using heat to sanitize water goes.
_________________________
The ultimate result of shielding men from the effects of folly is to fill the world with fools.
-- Herbert Spencer, English Philosopher (1820-1903)

Top
#93844 - 05/06/07 11:18 PM Re: A question about water [Re: benjammin]
norad45 Offline
Veteran

Registered: 07/01/04
Posts: 1506
Quote:
However, some organisms create toxins which can pass through filters and will not be destroyed by boiling.


And that right there is the rub. During the summer months I store 40 extra gallons of water (heavily bleached--more about that later) in the water tank of my travel trailer. During the day it gets to be over 90 F. (sometimes over 105 F.) I'm wondering if that water, if compromised by pathogens, can be made safe by boiling or is it risky no matter what?


Edited by norad45 (05/06/07 11:40 PM)

Top
#93846 - 05/06/07 11:42 PM Re: A question about water [Re: norad45]
silent_weapon Offline
Newbie

Registered: 10/11/06
Posts: 38
Loc: Oklahoma, USA
If it is chlorinated and kept from the light...it shouldn't grow any baddies...and should be safe long after 3 months... BTW in my oppinion, it is more risky not to drink water when dehydrated than to drink questionable water.

Top
#93848 - 05/07/07 12:20 AM Re: A question about water [Re: norad45]
MDinana Offline
Pooh-Bah

Registered: 03/08/07
Posts: 2208
Loc: Beer&Cheese country
That's a good question. To the best of my knowledge, all the crap that makes us sick tends to be either the organism, or a toxin made by it. Most toxins tend to be proteins, so I assume if you boil, you'll denature it and the protein will be rendered inert. But I've also heard that spores and prions are pretty robust. I wonder about them? I'll see if I can corner one of the microbiology professors in campus this week and give you a professional opinion!

I tend to agree with Silent Weapon: better to drink than dehydrate and die. After all, my dog drinks water from anywhere, and she's still around. You figure organisms have been dealing with the water on the planet a few billion years (if you believe in evolution), so I'm sure we can survive it still, generally speaking.

Top
#93852 - 05/07/07 01:45 AM Re: A question about water [Re: norad45]
CANOEDOGS Offline
Pooh-Bah

Registered: 02/03/07
Posts: 1853
Loc: MINNESOTA

the best answer is the story of the guys "down under" in OZ
some years ago..on a long treck in the outback they found the
only water hole had a dead and very rotten roo in it..the
horses would not even drink it..sooo..they strained the water
thru blankets..boiled it..put ashes from the fire in and boiled
it more..strained thru the blankets and let it cool and drank
..it still had a nasty taste but no harm came to them...

Top
#93861 - 05/07/07 03:34 AM Re: A question about water [Re: silent_weapon]
Ponce Offline


Registered: 08/14/06
Posts: 43
Loc: In the woods of Oregon.
I get my water by gravity from a creek and for free, have a filter in the garage and another one under my counter and that's it...... being doing it for seven years and I never being sick.

Have also a 3,500 and a 550 gallons tanks just in case there is a nuclear or gas attack and the open water becomes no good... have a line going from the big tank to my underground bunker.

When I go for a walk up in the hills I carry my straw water filter.
_________________________
"If you don't hold it, you don't own it"... Ponce

"To be ready is not"... Ponce

Top
#93864 - 05/07/07 04:37 AM Re: A question about water [Re: Ponce]
duckear Offline
Addict

Registered: 03/01/04
Posts: 478
Off the top of my head, I cant think of a bacteria in stockpiled water that makes a toxin such as you describe/fear.

If it were common, I would imagine you would hear about it.


Top
#93870 - 05/07/07 06:03 AM Re: A question about water [Re: duckear]
Susan Offline
Geezer

Registered: 01/21/04
Posts: 5163
Loc: W. WA
Botulism dies when cooked to 240ºF/116ºC, or boiled for 10 minutes.
Salmonella dies at 160ºF/71ºC.
E.coli dies at 160º/F/71ºC.
Typhoid dies when boiled.

Boiling takes place at 212ºF/100ºC

But if the water was bleached and not opened, how would contamination occur? There is no such thing as spontaneous generation.

Sue

Top
#93887 - 05/07/07 01:27 PM Re: A question about water [Re: Susan]
norad45 Offline
Veteran

Registered: 07/01/04
Posts: 1506
Originally Posted By: Susan
Botulism dies when cooked to 240ºF/116ºC, or boiled for 10 minutes.
Salmonella dies at 160ºF/71ºC.
E.coli dies at 160º/F/71ºC.
Typhoid dies when boiled.

Boiling takes place at 212ºF/100ºC

But if the water was bleached and not opened, how would contamination occur? There is no such thing as spontaneous generation.

Sue


But it is not safe to eat canned food that has been tainted no matter how much or how long you cook it. The organisms may die but the toxins they produced remain. I'm just wondering if the same critters eventually show up in water.

The trailer water tank is by no means a sealed system. I agree that it is unlikely to get contaminated in such a short amount of time, but it could happen. Although I store drinking water seperately, I'd like to have the extra 40 gallons for backup. Right now I'm planning on using it primarily for sanitation.


Top
#93888 - 05/07/07 01:29 PM Re: A question about water [Re: CANOEDOGS]
norad45 Offline
Veteran

Registered: 07/01/04
Posts: 1506
Originally Posted By: CANOEDOGS

the best answer is the story of the guys "down under" in OZ
some years ago..on a long treck in the outback they found the
only water hole had a dead and very rotten roo in it..the
horses would not even drink it..sooo..they strained the water
thru blankets..boiled it..put ashes from the fire in and boiled
it more..strained thru the blankets and let it cool and drank
..it still had a nasty taste but no harm came to them...


Heck, where I come from we call that soup. grin

Top
#93895 - 05/07/07 02:09 PM Re: A question about water [Re: norad45]
Arney Offline
Pooh-Bah

Registered: 09/15/05
Posts: 2485
Loc: California
Originally Posted By: norad45
...40 gallons of water that has been stored at +90 F. for 3 months.


I can't think of anything that will flourish in the conditions you describe that wouldn't be taken care of by boiling. Toxins must be created by some organism, but if the organism itself can't start growing first, there's no risk of ingesting the toxin.

But you do mention algae. I don't have any experience with RV's or trailers, but can you actually get algae growth in the water tanks when maintained properly? I would think it would require sunlight to encourage algae growth.

Top
#93898 - 05/07/07 02:50 PM Re: A question about water [Re: Arney]
norad45 Offline
Veteran

Registered: 07/01/04
Posts: 1506
Quote:
I can't think of anything that will flourish in the conditions you describe that wouldn't be taken of by boiling. Toxins must be created by some organism, but if the organism itself can't start growing first, there's no risk of ingesting the toxin.

But you do mention algae. I don't have any experience with RV's or trailers, but can you actually get algae growth in the water tanks when maintained properly? I would think it would require sunlight to encourage algae growth.


I think you and the others are probably right. Bleach + Boiling should do the job. As far as algae goes, the water tank on the trailer does receive indirect sunlight, but it will probably take more than 3 months to take hold. I guess I'll find out later this summer.

Top
#93901 - 05/07/07 03:23 PM Re: A question about water [Re: norad45]
benjammin Offline
Rapscallion
Carpal Tunnel

Registered: 02/06/04
Posts: 4020
Loc: Anchorage AK
I guess my initial concern is that, if the water has been properly treated and maintained, and there's still the likelihood of algael growth thereafter, then the water is not secured, and is being contaminated somehow. That being the case, where one lifeform can grow, so can others.

If, however, the water is secured such that no algae are present despite the presense of sunlight, then it is likely nothing else made it through the processing cycle that would somehow have survived. In addition to the algae, I would be looking for suspended 'floaties' in the water before consuming it as well.

High levels of UV and Ion Exchange mechanisms will breakdown all organic components in water, whether organisms, or by-products or organisms. You hit it with enough juice, it will render anything organic inert. Heat ain't the only way to get rid of it.
_________________________
The ultimate result of shielding men from the effects of folly is to fill the world with fools.
-- Herbert Spencer, English Philosopher (1820-1903)

Top
#93945 - 05/07/07 09:06 PM Re: A question about water [Re: norad45]
Anonymous
Unregistered


The Botulinum toxins (two-chain polypeptide with a 100-kDa heavy chain joined by a disulphide bond to a 50-kDa light chain, which is an active enzyme) produced by Botulinum spores can be destroyed by boiling the water. The Botulium spores though can still present a danger as they are more heat tolerant. I would suggest the following procedure to deal with any contamination. Firstly filter the water with a suitable commercial ceramic based submicron filter such as Katadyn Pocket Water Microfilter (this will take care of most bacteria) then boil the water for 10 minutes, rolling boil or to be really sure, use an old fashioned pressure cooker (will raise water temperature higher than 100 degrees Celsius), allow to cool, then give it a blast with a Steripen (should deal with anything that has any DNA that has not already been destroyed by heat treatment). Then whisk the water thoroughly to add some oxygen to improve the taste. To improve the flavor of the water so that it is potable a chemical after taste tablet could also be added. This should deal with any non-chemical contamination.


Edited by bentirran (05/08/07 01:54 AM)

Top
#93993 - 05/08/07 05:30 AM Re: A question about water [Re: ]
Susan Offline
Geezer

Registered: 01/21/04
Posts: 5163
Loc: W. WA
I don't think normal algae is harmful, with the exception of blue-green algae, which isn't a true algae but a bacteria, and that red-tide stuff that poisons shellfish, etc. To get regular algae, I'm pretty sure that most kinds have to be exposed to light, not warmth. And a lot of algae is caused by excess nutrients in the water.

From what I understand, water in a container isn't too much of a likely source of botulism.

Some excerpts from the Center for Disease Control (CDC) regarding botulism:

"Clostridium botulinum is... a group of bacteria commonly found in soil. These... organisms grow best in low oxygen conditions.

"In the United States an average of 110 cases of botulism are reported each year. Of these, approximately 25% are foodborne, 72% are infant botulism, and the rest are wound botulism... wound botulism has increased because of the use of black-tar heroin, especially in California.

"Foodborne botulism has often been from home-canned foods with low acid content, such as asparagus, green beans, beets and corn. However, outbreaks of botulism from more unusual sources such as chopped garlic in oil, chile peppers, tomatoes, improperly handled baked potatoes wrapped in aluminum foil, and home-canned or fermented fish.

For more info, see http://www.cdc.gov/ncidod/dbmd/diseaseinfo/botulism_g.htm

Top
#94012 - 05/08/07 12:47 PM Re: A question about water [Re: norad45]
desertrat1 Offline
Member

Registered: 02/16/06
Posts: 144
Loc: Kingman AZ
I could be wrong here, but seems to me that if algae and critters (i.e. water skippers, mosquito larvae etc.) are actively living in the water thats a pretty good indicator the water is safe after some purification.

If they are closed containers that were prepped before closing (Chlorine added) I can't imagine too much stuff growing in them during storage.
_________________________
What you know isn't as important as knowing what you don't know

Top
#94711 - 05/15/07 03:07 PM Re: A question about water [Re: norad45]
atoz Offline
Member

Registered: 01/25/06
Posts: 144
Loc: Nevada
You only have to heat the water to a point to break down the protiens for the microbs or their by products, which are protiens. This is 160 to 180 degrees F. You do not have to boil it for 10 minutes but simply bring it to the point where bubbles start to form. And even on the top of Mt Everst this will be about 160 degrees F. If the water is stored and sealed then there should be NO question of the waters quality.
cheers

Top
Page 1 of 2 1 2 >



Moderator:  Alan_Romania, Blast, cliff, Hikin_Jim 
November
Su M Tu W Th F Sa
1 2
3 4 5 6 7 8 9
10 11 12 13 14 15 16
17 18 19 20 21 22 23
24 25 26 27 28 29 30
Who's Online
0 registered (), 365 Guests and 56 Spiders online.
Key: Admin, Global Mod, Mod
Newest Members
Aaron_Guinn, israfaceVity, Explorer9, GallenR, Jeebo
5370 Registered Users
Newest Posts
Satellite texting via iPhone, 911 via Pixel
by Ren
11/05/24 03:30 PM
Emergency Toilets for Obese People
by adam2
11/04/24 06:59 PM
For your Halloween enjoyment
by brandtb
10/31/24 01:29 PM
Chronic Wasting Disease, How are people dealing?
by clearwater
10/30/24 05:41 PM
Things I Have Learned About Generators
by roberttheiii
10/29/24 07:32 PM
Gift ideas for a fire station?
by brandtb
10/27/24 12:35 AM
The price of gold
by dougwalkabout
10/20/24 11:51 PM
Man rescued, floating on cooler
by Ren
10/16/24 02:39 PM
Newest Images
Tiny knife / wrench
Handmade knives
2"x2" Glass Signal Mirror, Retroreflective Mesh
Trade School Tool Kit
My Pocket Kit
Glossary
Test

WARNING & DISCLAIMER: SELECT AND USE OUTDOORS AND SURVIVAL EQUIPMENT, SUPPLIES AND TECHNIQUES AT YOUR OWN RISK. Information posted on this forum is not reviewed for accuracy and may not be reliable, use at your own risk. Please review the full WARNING & DISCLAIMER about information on this site.