Hope you don't mind my bumping this thread...
*** Spoiler Warning ***
I just watched the movie – not bad.  But it bugs me when they take what appears to be a fairly accurate portrayal (for Hollywood) and then force the plot to a climax by doing something stupid.  
Ok, the crew chief reports that the hoist cable is damaged and in danger of failing.  Step one: briskly lower swimmers back into the water (they spent the whole movie treading water, another five minutes is gonna kill them?).  Access the situation, form a plan and act accordingly.  
In no particular order:
Possible plan A: Hoist both swimmers at once, always maintaining an altitude that is a survivable falling distance above the water.  
Possible plan B: Hoist one swimmer at a time, again at a safe altitude.  
Possible plan C: Disregard hoist cable as unsafe, toss the swimmers one end of a rope and secure the other to the helicopter using an approved anchor point.  Perform a “fixed-line fly away”.  
Possible plan D: Kick a life raft out the door, assume that they have read ETS and know that they should erect the canopy, and rescue them later.  This time use a hoist equipped with aircraft grade stainless steel cable rather than bailing wire.  
  
_________________________
 - Tom S. 
"Never trust and engineer who doesn't carry a pocketknife."