SIMON SAYS "What are the opinions of those who live in colder climates--"

PERFECT - If you want total coverage in extreme cold, wind and wet weather for extended periods, you won't be disappointed.

If the criteria is cheap, light, flimsy, cute or quiet or PC, there are alternatives.

Short answer; no. The material they use is stiff (on gen II anyway), and crinkly.

Simon says don't worry Ponder, that's one main reason I asked, because I didn't have any of those qualities in mind.