i may choose the Coughlan's brand. But i want to know which type is better? Thanks.

I use the StarFlash mirror, which is plastic.

Read the mirror section in Equipped.org for more info.

I've also used the BSA metal mirror, but it isn't nearly as reflective as the StarFlash. For me, glass mirrors are just too heavy and breakable.

One problem I have with the StarFlash is the aiming mechanism - I find it hard to use while wearing glasses. The two-handed aiming mechanism works fine for me though (hold mirror near eye, hold other hand out in line with target, then flash the hand in front of the target with mirror, sweep back & forth across hand/target).

Heed Cody Lundin's advice: get a military style, glass, signal mirror.

I have to balance weight, cost, and availability.

StarFlash I can get. Military is not as readily available. And I don't have military-style requirements.

-- Craig

The question "which mirror" invokes almost as much discussion as "which knife."

My personal thought process and opinion:

• For PSK purposes, plastic is better than glass (given weight, fragility and buoyancy characteristics).

• Plastic isn't as reflective as glass, so I shoot for the best plastic version I can get.

• My self-imposed rule for outdoor "stuff" – if the cost is under $25 for any item, then I'll get the best available, no matter that it might be considered "expensive" compared to competing versions. Especially important for one of the "essentials."

• I believe that Rescue Reflectors are the best-of-breed among plastic signal mirrors Rescue Reflectors. Each is handmade, and they're individually tested. Mr. Murray, the owner/maker, is somewhat of a "signal mirror" guru. If you visit the website, click the "Specifications" box at far-left for some interesting reading.

I've seen any number of independent comparisons on the web; here's one such at Sea Kayaker magazine: http://www.seakayakermag.com/2001/01Oct/mirror4.htm

And Doug includes a discussion here on ETS website.

I have no affiliation with Rescue Reflectors, other than being a happy owner.