I agree that basic and simple is better. I tend to prefer to carry items that are used all the time, rather than items that are stowed away and never touched. When in the field my gear tends to be in several places (pockets, around neck, in daypack) rather than in a common container. My non-field EDC is more compact - kept in a ziplock bag in a pocket of my "man bag".

One thing that isn't discussed here too much (maybe?) is the need for shelter. I tend to think that in a remote area a lack of shelter - leading to hypothermia - is a real big danger. My EDC most days has some large 55 gallon trash bags. When out in the woods camping or on hikes I bring my bivy poncho instead.

Also, mostly for your amusement, here is a list of the Boy Scout Outdoor Essentials. You may have seen it. I myself really like this list.

SCOUT OUTDOOR ESSENTIALS
Pocketknife
First aid kit
Extra clothing
Rain gear
Water bottle
Flashlight
Trail food
Matches & Firestarters
Sun protection (hat, sunscreen, lip balm)
Compass & Map

PLUS
Whistle
Insect repellant, when appropriate
Large trash bag
Toilet Paper, partial roll in plastic bag
Pencil & Notepad
50' paracord or 1/8" polycord

The main list matches your almost item-for-item.