Sheet aluminum will not stand up to any flame source as well as steel or Ti, it will work for a limited period of time. I would think for a survival situation it would last plenty long enough.
I've used the same throw away pie tin for melting wax over a low flame for a couple years now, and it seems to be doing just fine. It is getting a little beat up, but it still does the job.
Given time, even cast iron will not hold up to repeated firings. I can already see wear on my oldest skillets which are used often enough in open campfires. Ti will likewise ablate, as do any metals subjected to oxidizing action, just at different rates.
In fact, there are dutch ovens made of aluminum, some have been used over open fires for years. They do wear, but they remain just about as usable as anything else.
For survival, though, I don't reckon there's that much advantage of aluminum over steel insofar as weight is concerned. The only other concern then would be price, which can be significantly different.
_________________________
The ultimate result of shielding men from the effects of folly is to fill the world with fools.
-- Herbert Spencer, English Philosopher (1820-1903)