There is a bit to understand about dedicated donations. Meaning donations where the donor specifies where the donation should go.

First, I need to say that I am a National Red Cross Volunteer.

Just after 9-11, the Red Cross said it would be sure that donations for 9-11 would go to those affected. I don’t know the exact wording, but that was the intent. The result was a gigantic outpouring of donations which were, as specified, routed to those affected. Unfortunately, this restriction prevented using the donations for helping the responders (fire fighters, police, EMT’s), or any support functions. This all came from the general fund.

The Red Cross took a lot of heat for the large amount of assistance they provided to those affected by 9-11. Many said it was far in excess of the assistance normally provided. Yet the resources of the Red Cross are severely depleted. Especially after this summer. I am in Florida at the moment and the situation here is still very critical. Many are still without housing. The panhandle of Florida will probably take years to recover. The Red Cross presence in Florida and elsewhere was expensive and much of its financial strength has been exhausted.

Although my involvement with the Red Cross is mostly in the Technical area, I have gained an appreciation for the way the organization functions. It truly does provide assistance to those in need. There is no ulterior motive in their actions. No religious, political or other requirements, just assistance to those in need.

So, please consider that placing a restriction on your donations may have un-intended consequences. By all means, contribute to the charity of your choice. But if you respect the work of the charity enough to donate, please also respect their ability to decide how to best use those funds.