I've had one of each. the Vic had more tools, a saw being the useful extra, having bought it after the wenger which did not have one. I like them both, the main difference between them is that I've lost the more expensive Vic. and the wenger which I have been almost indifferent to cos it was so cheap has been the dog's body, and subsequently more useful over time. Though I would prefer to have the Vic. in my pocket on a short walk, with its sturdier construction, the wenger has been more the household knife.