Contrary to what I wrote previously:<br><br>You might be able to consider some of the fixed-blade suggestions after all, depending on your local policy. I've dug around a little bit more, and despite many verbal assurances that fixed blades "are not allowed", the only "policy" I can find is on page 78 of the current handbook, quoted here:<br><br>"Note: The Boy Scouts of America does not encourage the use of large sheath knives. They are heavy, awkward to carry, and unnecessary for most camp chores."<br><br>That leaves a lot of room for interpretation, but it's clear that fixed blade knives are NOT forbidden. I suggest you discuss it with your adult leaders and refer them to ETS if they have questions (I'd refer them to ETS, regardless...). If you have a practical fixed blade in your pack or in a safe sheath worn correctly, I don't see what objection could be raised.