>>>I have not been involved in the BSA for a long time, but I can't remember the BSA frowning on fixed blade knives. Maybe it was just my troop/pack or leader. <<<<br><br>As Tom mentions, it's a "discouragement," not a hard, fast rule or policy. Such suggestions are designed to help ensure a safe, secure environment. I feel that young, newer scouts have little use for a fixed blade knife. Older, more resposible (hopefully <s>) scouts with more camping experience could be allowed to have such knives. But I personally don't see a need for them to brandish them unless they are on a trek. and five mile hikes in a state park don't qualify. For most of the situations they'll encounter in a campsite, their pocket knives and the troop saws and hatches are better suited.<br><br>I was on a trip to Baraboo for an annual Circus World Museum overnight, sort of a camporee. One of the scouts favorite stops is an Army Suplus shop. One scout wanted to purchase a 6" fixed blade knife with his spending money. He was a younger scout and I didn't feel right about it. So I told him he could buy it, but I'd hold onto it until we returned and I'd give it to his folks to decide if he could carry it. He declined the offer <s>.
_________________________
Willie Vannerson
McHenry, IL