That does not sound like a very welcoming congregation.
My freshman year college project was to attend all 26 churches in my town. I found the Unitarians to be the most welcoming--and tolerant of MY beliefs--of them all.
You might find the people at
http://www.uufmc.org/better fit your needs, in spite of the diversity of their beliefs.
I only searched Ocala, you may have one closer.
Edit: Scheduling shouldn't interfere with Temple, either :-)