Both lists look like the National Association of Search and Rescue (NASAR) List shown here:

http://www.nasar.org/page/61/Pack-List-and-FAQ

As a choice for everywhere and all the time, I think they are good. Remembering that these lists are only required for taking the certification test (by NASAR) they should be modified by the group or individual for the situation at hand. In my opinion NASAR depends too much on "planning to improvise". Being able to improvise is an important skill (maybe second only to Mindset) but for SAR I like to plan to have the equipment I am likely to need.

Respectfully,

Jerry