First, I have no affiliation with CountyComm other than as a customer. I paid my own money for the radios I mention in this review and I never told them that I would write a review.
I'm a sucker for a radio. I've been in Amateur Radio for over twenty years and I have a collection of ham transceivers and broadcast radio receivers. I have weather radios, ham HTs and general purpose receivers scattered throughout my house and kits.
As far as being equipped to survive is concerned, I view the ability to receive broadcast radio in an emergency as potentially very helpful, both for gathering information and for entertainment if you're in a survival situation where you need to stave off boredom.
The primary receiver for those purposes in my primary emergency kit has been the CountyComm GP-4L, also known as their ETFR (Emergency Task Force Radio). Depending on who you ask it's made by Kaito (that's how mine is marked) or by Marathon. I paid $28 for mine in 2011, before shipping.
CountyComm specs:
Radio: 150 hrs at 40% Volume
Light: 70 Hrs
Frequency Range:
FM 76-109 MHz
MW 520-1740Khz
SW 5.20-18.30 MHz
SW1= 49 Meter Bands 5.20 - 6.20 Mhz
41 Meter Bands 7.10 - 7.30 Mhz
31 Meter Bands 9.45 - 10.45 Mhz
SW2= 25 Meter Bands 11.01 - 12.05 Mhz
21 Meter Bands 13.60 - 13.80 Mhz
19 Meter Bands 15.10 - 15.60 Mhz
16 Meter Bands 17.55 - 18.30 Mhz
Sensitivity:
FM < 10 microV
MW-AM < 1 microV/Meter
SW-AM < 30 micro V
Power Requirements:
3-4.5 Volts DC via side jack (no adapter included)
2 each "AA" batteries
Dimensions: 3.4" X 2.55" X .83"
Weight: 85 Grams not including batteries
Speaker: 40 mm in diameter, 4 Ohms, .25 watt
Earphone Jack: 3.5 MM, Earphones Included
(Instructions come in both French and English)
(Blister Packed)
Clock: 12 Hour Format with Wake Up to Radio Alarm Feature
chaosmagnet's features:
- Really small for FM/AM/SW capabilities, especially at this price point
- Strong sound from tiny speaker
- Low-power flashlight built in, can't be used while radio is on
- Built-in clock kept good time (off by about a minute over almost two years)
- Alarm function
- Brings in distant stations reasonably well
- Digital display easier to read for old eyes when tuning stations in
- Round 5V input plug to operate without batteries (never tested)
I've never been dissatisfied with it, but I don't use it a heck of a lot either -- it sits in my car's emergency kit. I have a roll-up clip-on antenna that I keep with it (I seem to recall it cost $9, which would bring the price difference to 32%).
When CountyComm came out with their replacement, the GP-5, I bought it, with the intention of demoting the old unit to a different kit that doesn't have a broadcast radio receiver. I don't know who the manufacturer is. Mine cost $44.95, exclusive of shipping, last week.
CountyComm's specs:
Radio: 225 hrs at 40% Volume ( 50% Increased Runtime )
FM – Stereo via stereo earphones / MW / LW / SW
FM – Stereo via stereo earphones / MW / LW / SW
FM Frequency range adjustable (76 / 87 / 87.5 ~ 108 MHz)
Antenna Length 18 Inches
450 Station Memories
Multi Tuning Methods: ATS, ETM, Auto scan tuning with 5 seconds pre-listening for both frequency & memory (VF / VM), Manual tuning 9K/10K AM tuning step selectable
Silicon Labs Si4734 DSP chipset
LCD Backlight
Key lock function
External AM antenna Jack
Built-in rechargeable function (USB jack, 5V) ( can use rechargeable batteries )
Size: 53 (W) x 159 (H) x 26 (D) mm
FM: 87 – 108 or 76 – 108 MHz
MW/ AM: 522 - 1620 (9K tuning step) or 520 – 1710 kHz (10K tuning step )
SW: 2300 – 21950 kHz
LW frequency: 150 – 522 kHz (available for 9K tuning step only)
Accessories include:
Power Requirements:
Stereo earphones
External AM antenna
Soft antenna
Carrying pouch
User manual
Power Requirements:
4.5 Volts DC via side jack (no adapter included)
3 each "AA" batteries ( Batteries not included )
Dimensions: 6.20" X 2.05" X .80"
Weight: 85 Grams not including batteries
Speaker: 40 mm in diameter, 4 Ohms, .5 watt ( 2 times the ouput of the GP-4L )
Earphone Jack: 3.5 MM, Earphones Included
chaosmagnet's features:
- Not a bad size
- Very strong sound from tiny speaker
- No flashlight built-in
- Built-in clock and alarm
- Brings in distant stations reasonably well
- Larger, backlit digital display much easier to read, especially in the dark
- Temperature and signal/noise display
- Battery power remaining display
- Comes with clip-on FM wire antenna and external AM ferrite bar antenna for bringing in remote stations
- Mini-USB power input for operating radio or charging NiMh batteries (comes from factory expecting primary batteries and won't attempt to recharge them unless you change that setting)
Comparing the two, I found the new one easier to operate. It has several scan functions, including "Easy Tuning Mode" that scans the local area for stations and stores them in temporary memory, making it super-easy to find radio stations in your area. This function worked well for me. The larger, backlit display was much easier to see. The tuning knob has detents built-in for each tuning step, so you spend less time fiddling to get the exact frequency of the station you're trying to tune in. And it has memories, which make it much easier to use if you take a few minutes to set it up.
I was surprised to find that there didn't seem to be any difference in sensitivity between the two for remote stations. It's easier to tune them in on the new one; the included external ferrite bar (it supplements the internal ferrite bar) makes tuning AM stations directionally much easier. It goes to and stays on the desired frequency without drifting.
Selectivity is noticeably better on the new one, for both close and distant stations. I imagine this is a function of the DSP, which the old one does not appear to have.
Bulk for the new one is a bit more; while the external FM antenna came with it and takes up less space than the one I bought for the old one, the external AM antenna makes up for it. Both came with serviceable earbuds; the new one's earbuds work in stereo and seem to be a bit better made.
Neither unit receives weather radio, which is a disappointment.
If they made the GP-5 in the same form-factor as the older GP-4L, this would be a slam dunk and I might buy another. As it is, for an emergency kit radio the new one is a bit spendy and bigger, but pays for it with significantly easier use. I'll keep 'em both.