JPicket,

Unscientific polls are just that - unscientific - and should not be used without a lot more information. It could be that the homemade stoves were being used by people who understood the tool (since they took time to make them and probably spent time learning how to use and fix them) and the other systems were being used by people who did not even read the directions. The homemade stove owners also had a self interest in "not having problems" since they had pride in their work. Commercial alcohol stoves seldom cause problems either. Gas canister stoves seldom give problems when used according to instructions. I have used lots of stoves over the years, most of them were problem free except for operator error.
Admittedly easier in a more complex stove.

Respectfully,

Jerry

There is a vast array of stoves from which to choose these days, and they will all bring water to a boil in a reasonable amount of time. I think I have used most major types at one time or another; for different circumstances, some are better than others. Dealing with major cold (-40F or so) you want a liquid fueled stove. Light weight? - alcohol, probably one of any number of home made varieties, or solid fuel (Esbit). Ease of use, adjustable flame,and reasonable weight - canister stoves.

If it weren't for the internet, I wouldn't know that there is a problem with stoves tipping over - I have never had that problem with any stove - just start with a stable base and exercise reasonable care. An effective wind shield and a decent lid on your pot are extremely important in obtaining cooking efficiency.

When all else fails, be sure you have the materials and skill to build a campfire out of available materials. It will be a bit fussier, but you will get to eat.

It is my understanding that alcohol stoves are banned from all National Forests. I have been told this by a ranger, but have not bothered to check it out. Seems like the tip over problem has caused some serious fires. I can see it happening too. It would spill and the fire is almost invisible. Not a good thing.

But check the rules of your favorite National Forest to be sure.

Nomad