A third option is a bivy bag. About the same weight and volume as a medium sized tarp, it can provide more weather protection.
A fouth option is a Hennesy Hammock.
A fifth option is a tarp-poncho.
Each of these options are single user only whereas a tarp of similar weight can provide shelter for 2 or even 3.
A 6th option is the tipi:
http://kifaru.net/tipis.htmlThough you could probably do this with a big enough tarp.