Originally Posted By: Bingley
Originally Posted By: Basecamp
I believe this, and many other articles, report dangerously misleading conclusions based on incomplete, misread or disregarded data


Would you care to give examples of the "incomplete, misread, or disregarded" data? If you have looked over the 200-odd cases Smith examined, I eagerly await your analysis of his data and why, based on the hard data, his conclusions are "misleading."

I have only read the two news articles. I haven't seem Smith's research article, which I assume presents his data and his findings. If you are in the same boat, then I don't see how your statement above has any worth.

Examine and present only 260+ case studies...that should only take a couple of weeks, would you like to pay my O.T. rate? laugh
Why don't you pick out an example of what you feel is definitive case or five that you think shows your point, draw a conclusion from it and I'll try to show where it may be misleading. Sound reasonable?