I bet somebody is reading this thinking, well, simply the knowledge of the primitive methods is important. My response is if you're going to make the trek out there to the woods, then natural materials should be used. Otherwise, the Scouts can just read a book or watch the 359 videos on Youtube where people are faking the primitive methods just the same. I just saw a guy on Youtube fake a primitive method by using jute twine, a large 2x4 from Home Depot, a shoestring, a nice sharp knife and other stuff. The video received all thumbs up. Well, let's see. If I used a cotton ball, a ferro rod and a scraper, then I would be using less pre-made material than him.
That's my only quibble with those who advocate planning on using primitive methods to start a fire. If your primitive method requires a modern forged knife, paracord or shoelaces & kiln dried wood it's not really primitive. Even making the concession for carrying a knife is kind of cheating- if you can have a knife, why not a ferro rod? I have tons of respect for those who can make the cordage by hand in the wild & create their drill set with a piece of sharp stone, but even that person would be hard pressed to do so when they're already lost- and out in the rain with the sun going down. Even such a noted primitive living skills expert as Cody Lundin advises people carry modern firemaking supplies & be prepared to survive.
Also, fire
preparation is at least as important to consider as combustion. I'd rather have a fire steel, a cotton ball and a good supply of dry kindling and small fuel than a pair of Zippos and damp green wood. Or at least I'd feel a lot better with a good knife, axe and/or saw to go with the fire steel than I would with a blowtorch trying to light logs. In a leisurely camping setting where I have time to create tinder, kindling and a couple sizes of fuel I'd bet you a hundred dollar bill I could get a raging fire going in minutes. Having that quality preparation would even more critical in a survival situation when the chips were down. What do they say- the worse you need a fire the harder is to make?