I have a Gerber Shortcut, Leatherman Squirt S4 and P4, and Micra.

I typically don't EDC any of them since I either have a LM Charge on my belt or a LM juice in my pocket, but I would go with the P4 if I needed something more on my keyring. I've never gotten around to getting a Gerber Clutch but I have been pretty happy with the Shortcut.