Well, we just had a similar case here in MA. Apparently, a 6 year old cub scout took his mess set (spoon, knife, fork combo) to school earlier this week. When the teacher saw it, the kid was immediately suspended for 45 days, and had to go to reform school-no questions asked. When interviewed, the superintendant said that was part of the "zero tolerance" that the school preaches. After being on the news all week, including several interviews with the parents & the poor kid, cooler heads prevailed. The superintendant was convinced that knee jerk reactions dont work-that the boy took it to school to eat with, because he thought it was a cool thing. So, he was only suspended for 5 days-which is still a tough call, as the kid STILL doesnt understand why he cannot go to school.
Zero tolerance is a lazy man's policy. I think these two cases, the one of the Eagle Scout, and the one with the Cub Scout, are clear examples of why blanket policies fail. The first one, there wasnt any REASON for it; the second one, the kid is too young to understand the sentence imposed on him. And, seriously...a 45 day suspension & 6 months in reform school-are were TRYING to create delinquency here?