Yeah, I did already have the knife. I got it for free years ago and it's the old style, tough as nails model Recon Tanto. It's in a very non-tactical looking sheath, so it doesn't look too menacing.

I said BIC lighter, but it's not the name brand, just a disposable see-through one with flame adjustment.

And that's not even close to being all that's in my bag, the rest would reside in the main pack. Some stuff I can't see putting in the butt pack (even if they would fit) like my Buck camp axe, Thermolite II bivvy sack, etc...

Some of the stuff would be a little redundant, like 10 or so feet of paracord in the small pouch, 50 feet in the butt pack, and 100 feet in the SHTF bag. A button compass in the pouch, Brunton 12NL keychain compass in the butt pack, a regular orienteering compass in the SHTF bag, and so on.

It's still all a work in progress, but I just don't like the all-or-nothing huge bag idea. I still always have my EDC stuff: compass, whistle, lighter, flashlight, pocket knife, Gerber Suspension, handgun, etc...