You are opposed to the eagle scout getting fined, but not this group. I dont see a lot of difference. Both made mistakes and had to be rescued. Using that rationale, shouldn't the eagle scout be held to the same standard?

I dont think ANYONE should be fined for having to be rescued. Generally, taxes pay for it, or people volunteer to help for no pay.

Whether my house burns down because of something beyond my control, like faulty wiring, or because of my negligence, the fire department doesn't send me a bill for putting out the fire. No difference IMO.