No argument that a 24-30" bow saw will beat all of these. Then again, give a choice between my pocket folder and my broadsword at an unpleasantness, I want the broadsword (if I can't bring something with a bit more oomph). This was a comparison of SMALL saws, which I'm more likely to toss into my pack for a day's hunt or an overnight camping trip than a full sized sword.

Now, if we are going to talk larger saws, what are people's thoughts on carrying just the blade of a bow saw, and scrounge a bow from the woods when needed (and using the smaller, fine work saw to make it).