I would hardly call the sparkie a novelty, but you are right that most people aren't familiar with how to use such implements. I've had bics fail, and I know I am not the only one here who has. I've also had ferro rods break, so it pays to take care and have a backup or two handy, regardless what your primary source of firestarting may be.

Ideally, I prefer to carry several different types of firestarters, and also to know how to make fire using natural implements, like a fire bow and drill, collecting natrual flint/churt, or even converting other supplies/tools to making fire.

Every one of my kits has a good butane lighter in it. My favorite is a $9.00 catalytic torch type that is watertight, windproof, and refillable. However, I have a couple of those 99 cent bics, with duct tape spooled on them (they make great duct tape holders)

Art you're essentially right. If you're not rushed read the first comment that started this thread. I stated that this is to replace my Sparklite, not my lighters which I also carry; a mini bic and a peizo butane lighter with water resistant gaskets. I also carry a zippo every now and then (mostly around town and to parties).

Its about the size of a mini bic though a tad wider. Maybe weighs less.

My entire focus is to make a fire. If I can do that with a bic lighter or a car's cigarette lighter or easier convenience, I could care less. The ease in which I start a fire is the overrider except for one thing--getting the fire started. If a dollar bic won't do it and that's the only option I had in the back country, I am screwed.

Which if you read my first comment you see I carry an extensive fire starting kit that I practice on a weekly basis and I might add probably weighs less than 9 oz.