Wow, those are some NICE pics!

Not sure that any of these knives are necessarily "better" at any one thing. Lots of the reason I'm ready to change though is how I fit the knife. The Kabar Mini handle is too narrow for me (though I think the blade is decent), whereas the Seal Pup blisters my hand. Plus it just feels too thick for some finer work, but that could be the grind of the blade. The USN pilot knife gets dull way to quick and the saw is near useless (IMO).

I really like that Pukko combo up there. You have a link or something where I can read more? Are those handles more comfortable than they look?

Normally I carry a BM Mini Grip camping, or more often a SAK Hiker. The SAK has done great over the years, but I always just felt a fixed blade should be carried more. As such, it's ideally going to be used to be better around the campsite: splitting wood, pounding in ground stakes, cutting rope, maybe whittling if I get bored, etc. Probably won't be used for food prep. I move a lot, but it'll probably be used in Michigan, and later, Virginia (so, what, deciduous forests?).

Thanks for the thoughts so far. If I can sell off my current knives, I think you're swaying me towards the F1 (with the S1 and now the Pukko in the running).