Ok...no one home and time for kitchen counter experimenting with some of the suggestions in this thread. Draw your own conclusions and do your own testing. I would be interested to see if anyone has different results.
Part # 11) Neopsorin (generic brand)
A dollop of cream on a good plate. I could not get this to light no matter how many matches I put to it. Maybe it is because it is the generic type...however it has all the same ingredients as the brand name Neopsorin...  
 
  Next up Hand Sanitizer (Thanks Blast, I like it). This one was the best.  
 
  It burns with a nice blue flame...and hot.  
 
 Next is Vaseline. It would not light on it's own.   
 
   However swabbing a couple of Q-Tips with Vaseline works.    
 
  The same Q-Tips did not light after they were sprinkled with water.  
 
  Mouthwash...had some unknown words on it so I thought I would give it a try...no flames with this though.  
 
 Aftershave...some old forgotten bottle of Stetson  
 
  It burns hotter then the hand sanitizer.  
 
  Back to the Vaseline, This time a bit of old 100% cotton t-shirt was coated and it caught fairly easy. 
