Originally Posted By: KenK
RSK Mk3 vs Rant Drop-point ...

--Though I don't own one (I have the Mk3 instead) I see the newer style BM Rant drop-point as a very nice knife for survival. It does have the features I'd look for, but ...

--I much prefer the exposed tang on the Mk3. It gives me a sense of confidence that the handle is REALLY full tang.

--I much prefer the G10 handle on the Mk3. I don't carr for the rubbery handled knives.

--I prefer the screws on the handle - so I can swap it out with the orange G10 slabs ... if DR ever can get those out. I'm waiting patiently, just like I did for the Mk3.

--I prefer the metal half-guard for strength - and I do prefer having some kind of guard.

--I've liked the deep blade shape on the Mk1's & Mk3. That feature is actually what made me buy my first Mk1 years ago.

--I'm glad that DR didn't thin the spine of the blade just behind the drop-point - like the Rant has. I suppose the thinning would improve stabbing efficiency, but that is not what my knife is used for. OK, I might have stabbed a watermelon to start slicing it, but that's about it.

--I really like the stonewashed finish on the Mk3. Doug says it offers extra corrosion protection - maybe, but I think it also just looks really nice.

--I may be one of the few that actually likes the Mk3 sheath over other possibilities. I like the attachment options it provides. But then again, I don't typically carry the knife on-belt, but rather in or on pack.


Ok fair comment. My absolute preferred knife in a TSTF situation is a Fallkniven F1. I have certain concerns regarding what I want the knife to do. No least of whom is the ability to dig, pry under bark etc and being able to stab with it. In situations where bodging up a spear to deal with large predators may be nessesary.
_________________________
I don't do dumb & helpless.