I have these same two knives (except my Craftsman is in stainless, the Clipper in carbon).

The Craftsman is our around-the-house knife. Stabbing into large boxes to cut them down to recycling size, etc. Just general purpose tasks. It is perfect for this use and cuts like there's no tomorrow. I hate the sheath, but what do you expect for the price? And I don't need much in the way of a sheath for around-home use. The knife-to-sheath fit is snug and you end up shaving off parts of the sheath unless you very consciously insert the knife just perfectly.

I like the feel of the Clipper in my hand better. And its looks (very subjective). I also like the sheath better (ignoring the stay-on-your-belt concern that was mentioned by thseng). I find knife-in-the-sheath retention to be adequate, but a little light. I doubt you'd lose the knife out of the sheath during strenuous activity, but losing sheath-from-the-belt would be more likely.

The Craftsman has a larger and more abrupt finger guard whereas the Clipper has a minimal one. Thus I think the Craftsman would be safer for those not well practiced in knife use, hence my decision to use that one for around-the-house duty where family and friends may get ahold of it.

Neither knife is a beauty to behold. They are quite functional, but not works of visual art. I like the carbon look of my Clipper better than the stainless look of my Craftsman. The carbon look says "we didn't put much work into final finish" whereas the stainless look says "chrome plated" (obviously it's not chrome plated, but it kind of looks that way).

I rate both knives as stellar in the functional and quality categories. I wouldn't hesitate a nanosecond to buy either of them again. They really are amazing in what they can do at their price point. If you want a show knife for your display cabinet ... look elsewhere. If you want a knife to use rather than gawk at, these babies will do that perfectly. Highly recommended.