I am not impressed at all with either of the guns you chose, quality is very suspect on both. I have never seen either one of these group or shoot worth beans, I personally like something with more punch too. Chris had the best idea of anyone with the single barrel shotgun.

Where I live you can buy a New England Firearms single shot 20 gauge for 79.95. Get a gunsmith to silver solder some rifle sights and you have a firearm that will take, with the right ammo, dove on the wing, whitetail deer, and anything in between. All for around 125 bucks, it is light and easy to carry, the added sights are for shooting slugs btw. Good luck with your choice