Hacksaw,

I will echo what LED says. Youze only gots one pairs of hoofers, so takes carez of 'em.

I have a high instep and high arch (weird genetics). The result is I need to wear custom orthotics. While the orthotics solve 99% of the support problem, the 1% leftover is the killer. It is near impossible to get my foot in any boot with my orthotics in them. If I find a boot that is OK, I usually end cutting out the insoles so my feet will fit better/correctly. It sucks.

Again, just like eyes and teeth; take of them. I agree on the Raichle. Meindls may be another option. Buy the boot for the purpose. As much as I know you dislike unitaskers, you may need to give way in this case. The off-road tire analogy is spot on.

All that to say this: Good luck!