That comparison is really telling! I was surprised that the Wetterlings outperformed the GB on every test. I've seen those Roselli axes too. I like the straighter handle and wedgier head for splitting. I also like that Hudson's Bay axe...seems to have the perfect dimensions.

I would never buy a hand forged axe with a wood handle online however...too risky.

I've been trying to find a place in Edmonton that sells forestry supplies...I think that's my best chance to touch and feel something of quality before I buy. I went to every hardware store I could find before I made that post and they almost all seem to have the typical fiberglass or poor quality wood handles, mass produced head with asymmetrical bevels, blunt edges, and awkward balances.

The exception are the Fiskars axes which are very good quality with strong, light handles. I've heard almost too many pros and cons to commit to buying one of these yet...their wide range of sizes make selecting just one hard too. I'm a huge Gerber/Fiskars fan which is why I'm hesitant...I don't want to buy just for the name...I want good product.