I've stocked up on those cheapo glass lanterns with the glass bowls. The kind you find at Wal-Mart, etc for $10 a piece. Several are more than a decade old now, and still work just fine. I've had to drain them off and refill them for moving purposes. They hold up well, unless the wife or kids knock them off the shelf while dusting or something.

Dietz, Aladdin, etc, all make pretty good household oil lamps. Hurricanes will do better for rugged use.