Yeah, I've not have very good luck luck with home-waterproofed matches. I've tried several coatings but they never quite burn as good as "naked" matches.
These days - at least around the home area with the Scout - I only carry naked strike-anywheres stored in a K&M long-sized aluminum matchcase. If I were heading into "real" wilderness I'd carry REI waterproof matches in the K&M case.
Ken