band -aid solutions for long term problems?

this thread has me thinking - Biulding a third world first aid kit

With my limited study of community health, I would think that classes on basic hygiene,* mosquito netting and a water filter would have a tremendously greater impact than a First Aid kit (most of Which will be used up in the first month.)

Gear planning is also a study of goals - what do you hope to accomplish?

Teacher

* and basic biology,

That would seem a good start, but I believe J-I was thinking of a kit to preserve the health of the Missionaries more than the indigenous people. Many people living in third world countries either have chronic infections or antibodies which protect against the same diseases. People such as missions teams haven't got those antibodies and may fall really ill while eating and drinking the same water and food as their hosts.

Protecting the care giver is my primary concern; I also design kits for the purpose of them being left at churches and orphanages.

I do inventory by trade but I have a passion for first aid medicine hence why my focus is on first aid kits. An interesting question has been asked: What do I hope to accomplish?

Jeanette Isabelle

I am a great believer in education and self-reliance. While some traditional ways and cures are useful, many are not.

It is my understanding the the great strides in western public health were made not from medications, but from sanitation. In the words from an old John Wayne movie "The coffee tastes better if the latrines are downstream."

IMO, looking to the sanitation and prevention of the transmission of diseases is a key service the mission folks can provide. How to do it is fact specific to where they are, so they may need to figure it out when on site.

"An ounce of antiseptic is worth a pound of antibiotic." --- quote from an old Doctor of mine. Prevention is cheaper than a cure.

So, what to accomplish? Education to avoid sickness and injury, and then, when that fails (it always does, at least for some), short term support (e.g. the first aid kits) and (hopefully) some prospect for more comprehensive/long term care. In the end, you are trying to buy time until help arrives. No kit can replace a fully staffed and equipped ER.

Keep up the good work!

"Do what you can, where you are, with what you have." I have no idea who said that but, Jeanette, I suspect they were speaking about you and thinking "Wow! She's doing a great thing!"

Some of us have small but important roles to play in the adventures of others but that doesn't mean our role isn't important or that we should assume responsibility for the whole thing. From what I can tell, JI is making an important contribution, as part of a much bigger picture. I don't think it's right to minimize it by asking a question like this. Missionaries should also get their shots, learn about the AO, pack extra underwear...

I don't think you're wrong about the importance of sanitation, etc., but I do think it's beyond the scope of JI's role in the project.

Sorry Teacher, I'm overly sensitive today and didn't mean to be defensive. My point was simply that, while it's interesting and informative to look at the bigger picture, it's beyond the scope of Jeanette Isabelle's project.

I do appreciate that (this?) discussion moved to another thread, I just wasn't happy about how that (this?) thread was framed. It seemed to me to be a MUSHY thinking line of thought, which I didn't think was fair. Then you went and explained yourself well and now I feel like an ass.

Cleaning up the world's water supplies would be #1 in my books to do the greatest amount of good for world health. There are so many water bourne pathogens, chemicals and just plain sewer garbage in so many people's water supply that kills and sickens so many people every day.

No, I think you got it spelled right. A carnet (a document that allows for temporarily transporting equipment across the border). I'm not sure about medical equipment but not having one tripped up Les Stroud on his recent trip to Belize with his crew. His camera equipment got held up because he was told he didn't need one (twice!). http://www.travelandescape.ca/2013/06/survivorman-meets-u-s-customs/

Good effort, TRO, but you are thinking too small. Infrastructure would in fact save more lives than missions. Hygiene, water systems? Small change, these folks need roads, utilities, school systems and non-exploitative governments! Sadly, it is beyond the ability of the first world to provide these things to the third world: see the effects of 200 years of well-intentioned work in Haiti. More poignantly, see the effects of our missionary work in the middle east, conducted not by Methodists from Ohio but by the powerful intellects and massive resources of the military and intelligence communities.

Missioning is hard, and JI is using exactly the right approach by supporting small, non-governmental efforts to do a little, temporary good by person to person contact, support and love. Missioning is retail work to make things a little better, and to communicate some level of personal concern. Nothing else works as well. Most everything else doesn't work at all.

"Nothing else works as well. Most everything else doesn't work at all."
Well Said!

I tend to focus on goals and what actions (or purchase) has the greatest impact.

Helping any community, be it your own neighborhood, church, school or a distant one requires thinking about what you hope to achieve and how.

Its ALL worth doing, but because of limited resources, make good choices