Any SAK's available without blades?

Posted by: haertig

Any SAK's available without blades? - 11/28/12 08:13 PM

I find the inclusion of knife blades on a SAK a waste of space for my needs. I always carry a seperate, better quality, more useful knife. The only SAK makers that I am aware of are Victorinox and Wenger, but neither of them make what I'm looking for that I can tell. And neither has any kind of "custom shop" where you can design your on SAK (that would be a very cool option to have IMHO!)

I don't really need a corkscrew either, never having found the need for an emergency bottle of wine. At least Victorinox has realized the idiocy of including this tool in 95% of their SAK's to some extent, by making a micro screwdriver insert that fits inside the coils, thus making the corkscrew somewhat useful (as a holder for an extra screwdriver).

An online "design and order your own customized SAK" would be a nice marketing opportunity I would think. Too bad nobody does it that I can determine.

Although I have a Leatherman Wave, amongst other multi-tools, I don't find them easy to carry (nor needed) on a day to day basis, and prefer the slimmer inside pocket carry profile of a SAK (without the "K" part, preferably!)
Posted by: ILBob

Re: Any SAK's available without blades? - 11/28/12 08:28 PM

you can sometimes replace the blade with something else yourself. spare parts are readily available.
Posted by: chaosmagnet

Re: Any SAK's available without blades? - 11/28/12 11:03 PM

For myself, I really like having a spare knife on my multitool. I would probably get rid of the serrated blade on my LM ST300, keeping the straight edged blade. I think it would be awesome if Leatherman offered a customizable chassis-based multitool solution.

There's one guy on EDCF (metropolicity) who has done some pretty awesome Leatherman and other mods I've seen. He's also behind the Skinth sheath.
Posted by: Denis

Re: Any SAK's available without blades? - 11/28/12 11:09 PM

The only thing that pops to mind are Leatherman's travel friendly tools (which all seem pretty pocket-friendly too). I guess it depends on what tools you would be looking for in a knife-free package.
Posted by: chaosmagnet

Re: Any SAK's available without blades? - 11/28/12 11:34 PM

With regard to the LM Style PS, I've brought one through airport security about half a dozen times so far without difficulty. While it would be a lot more useful for me if it had a small knife blade, I've been glad to have it a few times.
Posted by: ironraven

Re: Any SAK's available without blades? - 11/29/12 05:38 AM

Metropolicity is doing Leathermans only right now, but there are people at MultiTool.org who you might be able to talk into doing a build for. You might look at http://forum.multitool.org/index.php/board,16.0.html, particularly the stickied items at the top.

You might also decide to use a different form factor. The LM Wingman and Sidekick are ridiculusly easy to take apart, and Home Depot has one of them on sale for like $20- take it apart, and put it back together without knife blades and without the plier head, with some of the tools from other handle in the head even if you are willing to get fiddly.

Or buy yourself a pair of good tweezers, a pair of good, small scissors, a p38 can opener, and a cheap multibit screw driver small enough that all this fits in an altoids tin. Add a couple wire twist ties, a few paper clips, maybe a needle or two with some thread on them, a few tooth picks and a pair of nail clippers if there is still room. You could do that for the cost of a Vic Spartan or Tinker.

And I agree, being able to pick layers and combinations from Victorinox would rock.
Posted by: wileycoyote

Re: Any SAK's available without blades? - 11/29/12 04:16 PM

what about the "bladeless" models? (i don't know if they're still in production)

wenger air traveler #16912:
http://www.wengerna.com/air-traveler-16912


victorinox bladeless #47802:
Posted by: LesSnyder

Re: Any SAK's available without blades? - 11/29/12 05:38 PM

OK it has a blade... I don't read many comments about the middle sized multi tools... I was given this Leatherman Juice S2 for Christmas last year, and it replaced the Farmer in my EDC...I'm not a hiker, and more likely to use the pliers/ wire cutter and scissors than the saw (I carry a section of hack saw blade elsewhere)...it is slightly shorter, a little wider, and thinner than the Victorinox Farmer...the blade point is very handy for minor splinter surgery...



Posted by: haertig

Re: Any SAK's available without blades? - 11/29/12 06:23 PM

I was just wishing here. I don't need to spend a bunch of money having a custom job done on a SAK. I'll just carry the one I have, which has a little more than I really need (namely, the blades and corkscrew).

Really, what I use routinely are - all the screwdrivers (including the little one inside the corkscrew), bottle opener, toothpick, tweezers, reamer (as a fingernail cleaner, not a reamer). I've never opened a can with the SAK, other than to test if the can opener worked (it actually works fairly well), never opened a bottle of wine with it. I have used the blades once or twice, but so rarely that I'd just as well get rid of them and replace them with a file, a saw (don't know that I'd use that either), or a pair of scissors.

Here's my current one, not perfect, but not too bad a mix of tools - it's a Victorinox, a special make-up for REI years ago I think. It didn't come with the mini corkscrew-held screwdriver, I got that seperately from Victorinox. I like the phillips screwdriver built into the inside of the tool rather than off of the bottom as most are these days.

Posted by: LED

Re: Any SAK's available without blades? - 11/30/12 04:56 AM

Originally Posted By: chaosmagnet
With regard to the LM Style PS, I've brought one through airport security about half a dozen times so far without difficulty. While it would be a lot more useful for me if it had a small knife blade, I've been glad to have it a few times.


Same here. I travel with my Leatherman Style PS and I'm pleased with it.
Posted by: Hanscom

Re: Any SAK's available without blades? - 12/01/12 09:54 PM

Advantage of having a SAK with a blade is that it is a better knife to loan to someone who needs a blade than the Ritter Mini-Grip in my other front pocket.

People sometimes get stupid about what they see as this huge knife. No, a Gerber LST is NOT a Bowie knife; happened to me once.
Posted by: tomfaranda

Re: Any SAK's available without blades? - 12/01/12 10:22 PM

Leatherman has a retired tool, the knifeless fuse. Substitutes a file for the standard knife. But at 6 oz., may be too heavy for what you want. And hard to find now.

http://www.leatherman.com/products/product.asp?id=14&f=6&c=1
Posted by: haertig

Re: Any SAK's available without blades? - 12/01/12 11:19 PM

I like that knifeless Fuse. I will search eBay to see if I can find one. Thanks!
Posted by: yee

Re: Any SAK's available without blades? - 12/09/12 12:01 AM

Originally Posted By: haertig
I like that knifeless Fuse. I will search eBay to see if I can find one. Thanks!


drillspot.com apparently still has them in stock.

Thanks.
Conway Yee
Posted by: bacpacjac

Re: Any SAK's available without blades? - 12/09/12 11:20 AM

Originally Posted By: IzzyJG99
Originally Posted By: haertig
Here's my current one, not perfect, but not too bad a mix of tools - it's a Victorinox, a special make-up for REI years ago I think. It didn't come with the mini corkscrew-held screwdriver, I got that seperately from Victorinox. I like the phillips screwdriver built into the inside of the tool rather than off of the bottom as most are these days.



It's an "Explorer." One of the best and one of my personal favorite models. The "Explorer Pro" they sell now comes with the eyeglasses screw driver, straight pin and space pen now. If you like this model a lot you should see about picking up a new "Explorer Pro." They're like $25 on Amazon. I've got a couple vintage ones in my collection I whip out now and then for fun.


These looks likee just the SAK I've been looking for. Thanks guys!