Hmm, could you elaborate on why you're excited about tinder cards? How is it more than just wax + paper?
So far the list of pros:
*kind of laminated into layers
*rigid but easy to work with
*seems to be pretty water resistant
*burns long and slow from top
*burns bright and hot from the bottom
*score it with a knife and light it with a spark
*can be bought for $6.50 or so
Your strategy of vacuum-seal-into-zip-lock-mylar seems fantastic as a tinder carry option , esp long term
I'm not sure how the Tinder Card is manufactured. It smells a bit like beeswax but probably isn't. I like the stuff for the following reasons:
1) It's rigid. It's not structural strong like wood but more live heavy cardboard. This makes it ideal for several applications. For example I can cut rounds out of it sized to fit the lid of my UCO Match case and once pressed up in there it's stiff enough to stay there. It makes a great backing board, and it will stand up if you lean it up on something.
2) It can be be "frizzed up" while retaining its shape. You can score the top side of it or one end to the point where it can easily be lit with a spark while staying in one shape. Some won't care but I like that for the way I build fires.
3) It burns at a nice, controlled rate. Unlike paper that flares up it's more like a cotton ball soaked with PJ. It's candle-like.
4) Being rigid you can cut it to fit specific spaces. For instance I will often cut it into little sticks that I can slip into a match case.
I like to use it in conjunction with other products. For instance, a cotton ball is great in a match case because it stuffs it up to prevent rattling and works as tinder. But it burns very fast; coating it in PJ is great but it's not much good to pack around matches then.
Thanks, now I see why you're excited, carvability/sculptability ... not really a feature I look for in tinder

but it makes sense
The manufacturer says tinder cards are made from wood pulp and Stearin, like beeswax from palm oil (candle wax hardener), swedish version of wax+sawdust firestarters for bbq...
speaking of which, wax paper has a lot of the features you mention

Durable Wax Paper, 65-square-foot(~168g*18621 BTU/lb ) 6,897 BTU_IT / $1 = ~6,897 BTU_IT/$
tinder card, 18 strips * 10.7 grams ... 100% stearin 7,524 BTU_IT / $6.50 = 1,157 BTU_IT/$
tinder card, 18 strips * 10.7 grams ... 37% stearin 5,750 BTU_IT / $6.50 = 885 BTU_IT/$
tinder card, 18 strips * 10.7 grams ... 100% stearin 7,524 BTU_IT / $10.94 = 688 BTU_IT/$
tinder card, 18 strips * 10.7 grams ... 37% stearin 5,750 BTU_IT / $10.94 = 526 BTU_IT/$